Interventional Psychiatry/Neuromodulation
Journal Article Annotations
2024, 3rd Quarter
Interventional Psychiatry/Neuromodulation
Annotations by Liliya Gershengoren, MD
October, 2024
- Ketamine for catatonia: A novel treatment for an old clinical challenge? A systematic review of the evidence.
PUBLICATION #1 — Interventional Psychiatry/Neuromodulation
Ketamine for catatonia: A novel treatment for an old clinical challenge? A systematic review of the evidence.
Ana Teresa Caliman-Fontes, Flávia Vieira, Gustavo C Leal, Beatriz A Carneiro, Yana Quarantini-Alvim, Taiane V Andrade, Rodrigo P Mello, Ary Gadelha, Acioly L T Lacerda, Lucas C Quarantini.
Abstract: Schizophr Res. 2024 Sep:271:355-370. doi: 10.1016/j.schres.2024.07.055. Epub 2024 Aug 3.
Introduction:
Catatonia, documented since the 19th century, remains a significant challenge in terms of recognition and treatment. Over the last two decades, ketamine has brought new perspectives to psychiatry, sparking widespread interest. Concurrently, catatonia has attracted heightened scientific attention. Preliminary evidence suggests the therapeutic potential of ketamine for catatonia.
Methods:
We systematically searched Medline/PubMed, Embase, PsycINFO, Lilacs, and Cochrane Library databases, as well as Google Scholar, for studies with ketamine or its enantiomers as intervention for catatonia, with no restrictions to underlying diagnosis, date, language, or study design.
Results:
Twenty articles were included, encompassing a total of 25 catatonic patients receiving ketamine or esketamine. Predominantly female (61.9 %), with a mean age of 44.4 years, patients mostly exhibited manifestations compatible with the retarded subtype of catatonia. Mood disorders were the most prevalent underlying diagnoses. Ketamine was primarily administered intravenously over a 40-minute period and in multiple-dosing schemes. Mean response and remission rates of catatonic manifestations for the whole sample were 80 % and 44 %, respectively, with no reports of worsening catatonic features or psychotic symptoms. Only one patient discontinued treatment due to intolerable dissociative effects.
Conclusion:
Challenging the conventional contraindication of ketamine in psychotic disorders, current evidence highlights its potential efficacy, particularly in treating catatonia. Pending further research, we advocate reevaluating this contraindication, as it may offer a promising therapeutic option, especially for challenging cases. Preliminary evidence suggests potentially greater benefits for catatonic patients with underlying mood disorders compared to primary psychotic disorders.
Annotation
The finding:
This systematic review looked at whether ketamine could be effective in treating catatonia, a complex and sometimes treatment-resistant condition. Across 20 studies involving 25 patients, most of whom were treated with intravenous ketamine, 80% showed improvement and 44% achieved remission of catatonic symptoms. The review suggests that ketamine, particularly in mood disorder-related catatonia, holds promise as a therapeutic option, with minimal reports of worsening symptoms. Only one patient had to stop due to dissociative effects.
Strengths and weaknesses:
The review shines a light on a novel and potentially game-changing approach to treating catatonia, especially in cases where standard treatments like benzodiazepines or ECT fall short. However, it leans heavily on case reports and lacks controlled trials, which makes it difficult to draw firm conclusions. The small sample size and inconsistent use of standardized tools to measure catatonia severity are also limiting factors.
Relevance:
This study is highly relevant for consultation-liaison psychiatrists, as catatonia is frequently encountered in hospital settings. The potential for ketamine to be used as an alternative or adjunctive treatment in catatonia is an exciting prospect. Additionally, its application in patients with mood disorders may offer a new avenue for treatment in refractory cases, making it a valuable option in CL psychiatry.